People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I went to the old Canal Inn tonight with my dad after hearing about the story of the death seat. The in itself was very large and spacious. It was pretty dead for a Thursday night, but I was not complaining as it meant. We got served faster! I loved all the Christmas decorations they had up and that they had space for a band. Unfortunately, we were not able to stay for the bands performance tonight. My dad ordered a chicken Parm dinner which he said he really enjoyed. I ordered a chipotle burger, but I'm not sure that's what I received. The burger I got had onions and what I think was American cheese. There was no chipotle taste to it. It was delicious nonetheless though so I would be interested to see you with the chipotle burger itself tasted like. I was also disappointed that they did not have the death seat burger. Apparently they only serve it once a month on Wednesdays and you have to look on Instagram for one that is. I shall go back for that one day. ”
“ Great service, good food, wonderful pace to go and visit the Death Chsir on Halloween. ”
“ We recently held a memorial service for my father at The Old Canal Inn. Mark and his staff were professional, detail oriented, and kind. The food and atmosphere were incredible. They welcomed us and our guests like family. My dad loved to go there for a beer and I understand why. I will visit there every time I am back in the area from Massachusetts. I can't recommend The Old Canal Inn highly enough. ”
“ Best around the area for sure owners and bartenders take care of you like family great for events ”
“ Had a very nice dinner here. Excellent burger. Service was very friendly and a cool looking place. We will definitely go back soon. Chill spot for a nice relaxing meal. Would love to come back and hear some music. ”
“ Great local bar. Dive bar vibes. They have shuffle board and darts for some fun and games. Decent beer selection. The food is typical bar fare. Service is great. My bar tender Amanda was friendly and quick. I have a feeling if you come more then once they really will "know your name". They also have a pretty big outdoor seating area. ”
Menu
Asian Salad
$12.00Chicken Quesadilla
$9.95Coconut Shrimp
$9.25Italian Wrap
$9.00Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
$8.75
About
The Old Canal Inn
Welcome to The Old Canal Inn: a hidden gem nestled in Nutley, NJ, where New American cuisine meets warmth and hospitality. With its inviting atmosphere and rich stories—like the notorious 'death seat'—this restaurant offers more than just food; it cultivates memorable experiences. Whether you're here for a casual lunch, a lively dinner, or a late-night gathering, The Old Canal Inn stands out as a versatile dining destination.
- Location: Situated at 2 E Passaic Ave, Nutley, NJ, it’s easily accessible for both locals and visitors.
- Dining Experience: The restaurant boasts outdoor seating, making it ideal for relaxed summer evenings, while its spacious interior accommodates groups comfortably.
- Menu Highlights: With a variety of vegetarian options and weekly specials—like the elusive 'death seat burger,' served only once a month—there's always something new to try.
- Live Entertainment: Enjoy live music on weekends, enhancing the casual, vibrant ambiance that keeps guests returning.
The Old Canal Inn is perfect for enjoying comfort food with friends and family. As Nick S. mentioned in his review, the service can be quick even on quieter nights, allowing patrons to savor each dish without rush. Whether it’s a classic chicken Parm that evokes nostalgia or the excitement of trying a new chipotle burger (despite the mix-up in flavors), each menu item is crafted thoughtfully and served with a personal touch. The presence of a full bar and happy hour specials adds to this vibrant culinary experience, making it a top choice for late-night outings or weekend celebrations.
For special events, Kira B. shared how the dedicated staff treated her family with utmost respect and care during a memorial service, showcasing the establishment's commitment to community and connection. With amenities like on-site parking and free Wi-Fi, The Old Canal Inn is tailored for guests who seek not just a meal, but a welcoming environment where memories are created.
Let's not forget the additional fun elements, such as the pool table and dance space, making it an engaging spot for evenings filled with laughter and entertainment. If you're in the area, be sure to swing by and experience the charm. As regulars like Ryan S. affirm, it’s easy to see why the owners and bartenders here treat you like family; they genuinely care about each guest’s experience.
So grab your friends, bring your family, and discover why The Old Canal Inn is more than just a restaurant—it's a beloved gathering place. Don’t forget to check out the Instagram for those sought-after specials! Your next adventure in taste awaits you!
Book a table